The Challenges of Memorializing

In light of the recent controversy surrounding the Eisenhower Memorial in Washington DC, and observations from a recent trip to Japan, Christopher Hawthorne pens an opinion piece on memorials - the "eternally fraught corner of design practice.

2 minute read

March 21, 2012, 12:00 PM PDT

By Jonathan Nettler @nettsj


In reflecting on his recent trip to Japan and future efforts to memorialize the 19,000 who perished as a result of last year's earthquake and tsunami, Hawthorne ruminates on recent memorializing processes in the United States - at the World Trade Center, to Martin Luther King Jr., and to President Eisenhower - and sees an opportunity, and need, to rethink the processes and products of memorial design.

For Hawthorne, a visit to a giant red fish-oil tank, mangled by the tsunami and sitting in a median in Ishinomaki, Japan, that he describes as an "odd piece of apocalyptic detritus", provides a potent symbol of the disaster.

It reflecting on "how overpriced and underwhelming so many traditional memorials have turned out to be in recent years," Hawthorne finds inspiration from his Japanese experience. "By contrast, the mangled red can in Ishinomaki eludes both bombast and easy readings. The way it manages to suggest two very different scales simultaneously - the quotidian scale of the supermarket shelf and the stunning strength of the tsunami - gives it some Pop art shadings and makes it even more artistically meaningful than, say, the twisted steel beams from the World Trade Center that will go on display at the Sept. 11 museum."

Also of note, on the subject of memorials, is a report by Philip Kennicott in The Washington Post on yesterday's congressional hearing on Gehry's Eisenhower Memorial design. At the hearing, Susan Eisenhower, granddaughter to the President, and representing the family, called for scrapping the current design, which she comapred to, "Communist-era decorations that honored 'Marx, Engels and Lenin.' She likened large columns that will be used to hang the metal scrims to 'missile silos,' mentioned Ho Chi Minh and Mao, and argued that Holocaust survivors were affronted by the similarity of the tapestries to the fences of Adolf Hitler's death camps."

According to Kennicott, "It's not clear whether Congress will reopen the [memorial design] process, especially given that eight of the Memorial Commission's 12 members serve in Congress. And while there has been growing momentum for revisiting the Gehry design among traditionalists and culture warriors, concern about the design hasn't coalesced into a coherent critique."

Thursday, March 15, 2012 in Los Angeles Times

portrait of professional woman

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching. Mary G., Urban Planner

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching.

Mary G., Urban Planner

Get top-rated, practical training

Aerial view of single-family homes with swimming pools in San Diego, California.

San Diego to Rescind Multi-Unit ADU Rule

The city wants to close a loophole that allowed developers to build apartment buildings on single-family lots as ADUs.

March 9, 2025 - Axios

Canadian flag in foreground with blurred Canadian Parliament building in background in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.

Has President Trump Met His Match?

Doug Ford, the no-nonsense premier of Canada's most populous province, Ontario, is taking on Trump where it hurts — making American energy more expensive.

March 11, 2025 - Toronto Star

Close-up of green ULEZ sign in London, UK.

Study: London ULEZ Rapidly Cleaning up Air Pollution

Expanding the city’s ultra low-emission zone has resulted in dramatic drops in particle emissions in inner and outer London.

March 10, 2025 - Smart Cities World

Tents set up by unhoused people under freeway overpass in San Jose, California with American flag above them.

San Jose Mayor Takes Dual Approach to Unsheltered Homeless Population

In a commentary published in The Mercury News, Mayor Matt Mahan describes a shelter and law enforcement approach to ending targeted homeless encampments within Northern California's largest city.

March 14 - The Mercury News

Blue Atlanta streetcar on street in downtown Atlanta, Georgia.

Atlanta Changes Beltline Rail Plan

City officials say they are committed to building rail connections, but are nixing a prior plan to extend the streetcar network.

March 14 - Saporta Report

New York City city hall building.

Are Black Mayors Being Pushed Out of Office?

The mayors of New York, St. Louis, and Pittsburgh all stand to lose their seats in the coming weeks. They also all happen to be Black.

March 14 - Governing

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.