If Gov. Gavin Newsom signs legislation by San Francisco Assemblyman Phil Ting, motorists who want to drive the 'world's most crooked street,' a huge tourist draw, will be forced to participate in a pilot 'reservation and pricing program.'
While not exactly 'Manhattan-style congestion pricing,' where drivers headed south of 60th Street will be subject to a hefty toll come January 2021, the Lombard Street 'reservation fee' had to clear the same legislative hurdle, as the state Assembly press release (source article) indicates.
The bill by Assemblymember Phil Ting (D-San Francisco) is necessary because existing law prohibits a local agency from imposing a tax, permit fee, or other charge for the use of its streets or highways.
The bill, "AB 1605: City and County of San Francisco: Crooked Street Reservation and Pricing Program," passed the Assembly on a 54-23-2 vote on Thursday. Gov. Newsom (D), the city's mayor from 2004 to 2011, has until Oct. 13 to sign or veto it. If he signs, the next step would be in the hands of the Board of Supervisors of the City and County of San Francisco, according to the bill's text:
This bill would authorize the Board of Supervisors of the City and County of San Francisco by ordinance to conduct a reservation and pricing pilot program for vehicles that use the “Crooked Street,” which the bill would define to mean the portion of Lombard Street located between Leavenworth Street and Hyde Street in the City and County of San Francisco.
Before the board of supervisors adopts an ordinance to conduct the pilot program, the bill would require the board of supervisors to make certain findings and to conduct at least 2 public outreach meetings or hearings...
The reservation program would be an all-electronic system, supported by a website, mobile app, and possible on-street kiosks to enable reservations, payments, and user support, according to the Sept. 4 legislative analysis. It states that the "current plan is for a staff [sic] onsite to check reservations, through paper and electronic means, and help direct vehicles, operating from 9:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. and cost $5 on weekdays and $10 on weekends and holidays."
Unlike the Manhattan plan and all other cordon pricing schemes being considered by large cities in the U.S., including San Francisco, AB 1605 encountered no formal opposition. Yet pricing streets, even more so than parking, is inherently controversial, explaining why 28 percent of legislators in both chambers opposed the bill.
Other alternatives considered
The seven-year pilot program fits the description of road pricing, a type of tolling, which was one of several considerations to deal with the street congestion, as noted in a September 2016 post on a study conducted by the San Francisco County Transportation Authority:
After a year researching how other tourist destinations handle similar problems, the study is now exploring solutions—including barring cars and turning the area into a pedestrian-only plaza...Other proposals include hiring a mass of parking and safety officers, requiring reservations, and charging a toll.
The fact that a car ban was not selected, yet was considered, is noteworthy. In essence, the authority chose a market-based measure to manage demand over the simpler, but arguably more extreme, ban, which presumably would not have required state legislation.
Assuming the governor signs AB 1405, chalk this pricing initiative up as a win for the Transportation Authority and Assemblyman Ting. The authority's Pricing & Incentives webpage lists three additional, ongoing projects:
- Carpool and express lanes on freeways
- Downtown congestion pricing
- A toll to enter and exit Treasure Island
Additional reading:
- Tourists May Soon Have to Pay to Drive San Francisco’s Lombard Street, Associated Press, Sept. 6, 2019
- Gridlock At The World-Famous “Crooked Street” Prompts Legislation To Soothe Residents' Woes, San Francisco Magazine, Aug. 23, 2019
Related in Planetizen:
-
Crowds of Pedestrians Prompt Lombard Street Study, September 22, 2016
-
SF's Congestion Pricing Plan Advances, November 15, 2010
Hat tip to Nannette Miranda.
FULL STORY: Ting Proposal for Reservation & Pricing System On World Famous Lombard Street Heads to the Governor
Social Equity Cited in Veto of California Road Pricing Bill
Gov. Gavin Newsom vetoed a unique road pricing bill due to concerns that charging a fee would limit access to driving on two blocks of Lombard Street, a popular tourist attraction in San Francisco that is severely congested.
San Francisco Supervisors Cool to Express Lanes on City's Freeways
The county agency that had hoped to do downtown cordon pricing now wants to add express lanes on Highways 101 and 280, but city supervisors are divided on charging solo drivers the option to buy into managed lanes. Both freeways lack carpool lanes.
More EV Charging Coming to San Francisco Private and Public Parking Facilities
To reach an ambitious net-zero target for transportation emissions in San Francisco, Mayor Breed and two supervisors introduced legislation to require large parking facilities provide electric vehicle charging for 10% of spaces.
What ‘The Brutalist’ Teaches Us About Modern Cities
How architecture and urban landscapes reflect the trauma and dysfunction of the post-war experience.
‘Complete Streets’ Webpage Deleted in Federal Purge
Basic resources and information on building bike lanes and sidewalks, formerly housed on the government’s Complete Streets website, are now gone.
Downtown Los Angeles on the Rise: A Promising 2025
Fueled by new developments, cultural investments, and a growing dining scene, downtown Los Angeles is poised for significant growth in 2025, despite challenges from recent wildfires and economic uncertainties.
Supporting Indigenous Land Reclamation Through Design
Harvard students collaborated with the Sac and Fox Nation to develop strategies for reclaiming and co-managing ancestral lands in Illinois, supporting Indigenous sovereignty through design, cultural storytelling, and economic planning.
A Plan to Expand Tree Canopy Across Dayton
Dayton is developing an urban forest master plan, using a $2 million grant to expand its tree canopy, address decades of tree loss, and enhance environmental equity across the city.
Decarbonizing Homes: The Case for Electrifying Residential Heating
A new MIT study finds that transitioning residential heating from natural gas to electric heat pumps can significantly reduce carbon emissions and operational costs.
Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools
This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.
Planning for Universal Design
Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.
Economic & Planning Systems, Inc.
UCLA Lewis Center for Regional Policy Studies
Mpact (formerly Rail~Volution)
Chaddick Institute at DePaul University
City of Piedmont, CA
Great Falls Development Authority, Inc.
HUDs Office of Policy Development and Research